• NEW LOCATION 40 S. Prospect St., Suite 102 Roselle, IL 60172
  • 630.980.8333
  • info@martuccilaw.com
Gregory Martucci lawyer logoGregory Martucci lawyer logoGregory Martucci lawyer logoGregory Martucci lawyer logo
  • Practice Areas
    • Bankruptcy
    • Criminal Defense
    • DUI and Traffic Defense
    • Juvenile Law
    • Personal Injury
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Civil Litigation
    • Other Legal Services
  • Attorneys
  • Bits N Briefs
  • Legal Resources
  • Contact
✕

Old Memories as New Evidence

  • Home
  • Bits N Briefs
  • Bits N Briefs
  • Old Memories as New Evidence
Martucci Law - BCC Member
Bloomingdale Chamber Member of the Month – Martucci Law
June 28, 2018
19 New Illinois Laws for 2019
January 22, 2019
Published by Greg Martucci at September 24, 2018

How Reliable are Old Memories of Sexual Abuse?

In a few days, a woman may testify before the U.S. Congress about her recollection of an attempted sexual assault, allegedly committed 36 years ago by a then intoxicated 17-year old high school student, who is the current nominee for a lifetime appointment as Justice of the United States Supreme Court.

How reliable will her testimony be?  Many articles can be found on the internet supporting the validity of recovered memories of childhood sexual abuse, which were previously repressed.  Lawmakers have accepted this view and expanded statutes of limitations in both criminal and civil cases to allow victims an opportunity to present their evidence and seek justice for physical and emotional injuries, even those occurring long ago.  This is an exception to the general purpose of statutes of limitation, which put limits on the time period to pursue claims, recognizing that after the passage of time, memories may fade, witnesses may be lost, and discovering the truth is more difficult.

Could old memories be unreliable?  Many articles on the internet also suggest that old memories may be unreliable and could have been suggested or implanted by therapists.  Nevertheless, the victim believes the memory to be true and accurate. Perhaps it’s reasonable to believe that a victim of a traumatic event is more likely to remember the details of that event than an ordinary event such as what she may have eaten or worn on a past occasion.

What is the truth?  The real truth may only be known to God.  But in the legal system, truth is determined by allowing the victim to testify (tell her story under oath, under penalty of perjury), allowing the accuser (or his advocate) to cross examine the victim to test her memory, question her veracity, or explore her motives, bias or prejudice.  All of this is weighed on a scale called “the burden of proof” or “standard of proof” which in a criminal case requires “proof beyond a reasonable doubt,” but less in a civil case, which requires only a finding of “more probably true than not true.”

Who decides what is the truth?  Depending on the forum, what is true may be decided by an arbitrator, a judge, a jury, a majority of jurors, or a majority of representatives or senators.  Sometimes this majority may require a vote of two-thirds, or sixty percent or one more than half.

Through what lens is the truth being viewed?  Like every other human being, judges, jurors, congressmen and senators have their own inherent biases and prejudices, born of their personal history, race, religion, wealth, poverty, education, experience, gender, political affiliation and many other factors.

What do we do with the truth?  In the court system, we accept that a judge or jury’s determination of the truth can form the basis for convicting or acquitting a person charged with a crime or awarding monetary damages in a civil case.  In the case of a congressional hearing involving an accuser and a judge, about conduct from 36 years ago, and what impact the truth may have on the nominee’s current judicial qualifications, the rules have not yet been written.

If you currently have or may have a case in the court system, with both sides claiming the truth, you need a good lawyer on your side.  Greg Martucci is a good lawyer who will aggressively prosecute or defend your civil case, or defend you against criminal, traffic or DUI charges.  He will utilize over 30 years’ experience in negotiations, litigation and advocacy to achieve excellent results, maximize compensation, or minimize adverse consequences.  Call Martucci Law today at 630-980-8333 to schedule your free initial office consultation and learn more about how we can help you right a wrong or fight injustice.

Share

More Bits N Briefs

  • Don’t Fall for Phone Scams

    Don’t Fall for Phone Scams

    December 9, 2022
  • Does Illinois’ SAFE-T Act keep us safe from violent criminals?

    Does Illinois’ SAFE-T Act keep us safe from violent criminals?

    September 14, 2022
  • Those Things We Do!

    Those Things We Do!

    March 29, 2022
  • 22 New Illinois Laws for 2022

    22 New Illinois Laws for 2022

    January 15, 2022

Need Help? Contact Us for a FREE Initial Office Consultation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Memberships/Affiliations

Bits N Briefs

  • Don’t Fall for Phone Scams

    December 9, 2022
  • Does Illinois’ SAFE-T Act keep us safe from violent criminals?

    September 14, 2022
  • Those Things We Do!

    March 29, 2022
Better Business Bureau Accredited Business

Contact Us

info@martuccilaw.com

630.980.8333

630.980.8404

NEW LOCATION
40 S. Prospect St., Suite 102
Roselle, IL 60172

Get Directions

The information you obtain from this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established as any information submitted could be used by us in the event we represent an adverse party now or in the future. Legal advice cannot be given without full consideration of all relevant information relating to the visitor's individual situation for which a full consultation is necessary. We offer a free initial office consultation to prospective clients.

Copyright © 2023 Law Office of Gregory J. Martucci, P.C.